Understanding Key Property Documents: A Guide for Landlords and Tenants
posted 14th November 2024
When dealing with leases, it’s crucial to be familiar with essential property documents, such as the Schedule of Condition, Schedule of Dilapidations, and Scott Schedule. Here's a detailed overview:
______________
1. Schedule of Condition (SOC)
Purpose:
The Schedule of Condition documents the existing state of a property at the start of a lease or agreement.
Contents:
• Comprehensive descriptions and photographs detailing the property's condition.
• Notes any existing damage, wear, or issues.
Usage:
• Helps to limit a tenant’s liability for returning the property in better condition than it was initially.
• Serves as evidence if disputes arise over repairs or reinstatement at the end of the lease.
Who Prepares It:
• Typically prepared by a building surveyor before the lease begins.
______________
2. Schedule of Dilapidations
Purpose:
The Schedule of Dilapidations outlines the tenant’s breaches of lease obligations, mainly concerning maintenance, repairs, redecoration, or reinstatement.
Contents:
• A detailed list of specific lease breaches.
• A breakdown of the required works to rectify these breaches, along with associated costs, if necessary.
Usage:
• Commonly issued by the landlord near the end of or after the lease term.
• Ensures the tenant meets their lease obligations, like repairing damages or reinstating alterations.
Who Prepares It:
• Usually prepared by a landlord’s surveyor.
______________
3. Scott Schedule
Purpose:
The Scott Schedule is a structured document used to summarize and resolve disputes, often in legal or arbitration contexts.
Contents:
• Presented in a table format, listing each disputed item, with columns for each party’s position, evidence, and comments.
Usage:
• Primarily used in dilapidations disputes or other property disagreements.
• Simplifies complex cases by clearly laying out the issues and each side’s arguments.
Who Requires It:
• Often requested by a court, arbitrator, or mediator to assist in dispute resolution.
______________
When is a Scott Schedule Required?
A Scott Schedule isn’t necessary for every case. It becomes essential when:
• There is a significant dispute over a Schedule of Dilapidations.
• Legal proceedings, arbitration, or mediation are involved, requiring a clear presentation of each party’s arguments.
Example: If a tenant disputes the landlord’s claims in the Schedule of Dilapidations, a Scott Schedule may be used to set out both parties’ positions in an orderly manner.
Key Differences
• Purpose:
o Schedule of Condition: Records the existing condition of the property.
o Schedule of Dilapidations: Lists tenant’s breaches of lease obligations.
o Scott Schedule: Resolves disputes in a structured format.
• Timing:
o Schedule of Condition: Prepared at the start of the lease.
o Schedule of Dilapidations: Issued towards the end of or after the lease term.
o Scott Schedule: Used during disputes or legal proceedings.
• Who Prepares It:
o Schedule of Condition: Prepared by a tenant or landlord’s surveyor.
o Schedule of Dilapidations: Prepared by a landlord’s surveyor.
o Scott Schedule: Prepared by both parties, often guided by a court, arbitrator, or mediator.
• Format:
o Schedule of Condition: Written report with photographs documenting condition.
o Schedule of Dilapidations: Detailed list of breaches, sometimes including costs.
o Scott Schedule: Table format with each party’s positions and evidence.
